One of them says, "I gotta admit, I'm scared out here."
To which the other replies, "You're scared…I gotta walk back alone."
Okay, here’s my “Joke Poo” version of the mafia joke:
Joke Poo: Astronaut Angst
Two astronauts are on a spacewalk, tethered to the International Space Station, millions of miles from Earth.
One nervously says, “I gotta admit, I’m feeling a little claustrophobic out here.”
The other replies, “Claustrophobic? I’m the one who has to go back inside with all those unwashed cosmonauts!”
Alright, let’s break down this joke:
Joke Dissection:
- Premise: Two mafia hitmen, known for their ruthlessness, are in a potentially dangerous situation (the middle of a dark forest). The inherent irony lies in the fact that these guys inflict fear, not experience it.
- Setup: One hitman expresses fear, subverting the expected hardened criminal persona.
- Punchline: The other hitman’s reply twists the fear dynamic. It’s not about being in the forest, but about the task at hand (presumably, the fate of the person they’re meeting). The fear stems from the consequences of their actions. There is also a bit of dark humor/threat in his reply.
Key Elements:
- Mafia/Hitmen: Associated with violence, power, and a lack of empathy.
- Fear: An emotion typically suppressed or hidden by such individuals.
- Irony: The contrast between expectation and reality.
- Forest Setting: Creates a sense of isolation, danger, and anonymity.
- The “Walk Back Alone”: Implies something bad is about to happen and the second hitman has to deal with the aftereffects.
Comedic Enrichment & New Material:
Let’s leverage some factual tidbits about forests and the Mafia, combined with the existing joke elements:
Tidbit 1: Forest Communication Did you know that trees in a forest communicate with each other via an underground network of fungal threads called the “Wood Wide Web”? They can share nutrients and even send warning signals about pests or diseases.
New Joke Idea:
Two Mafia hitmen are walking deep into a forest in the middle of the night, looking for the informant they’re supposed to “silence.”
One says, “I gotta admit, I’m scared out here. All these strange noises…”
The other replies, “Yeah, well, maybe he told these trees about what we’re here to do. Just hope they don’t use that “Wood Wide Web” to call for backup… roots and all.”
Amusing Observation:
You know, it’s funny. A bunch of guys who make a living ensuring people go to sleep with the fishes are suddenly afraid of what might be rustling under the trees.
Tidbit 2: Mafia Code of Silence (Omertà): A strict code that emphasizes silence and non-cooperation with authorities. Breaking it can result in severe consequences, including death.
New Joke Idea:
Two Mafia hitmen are walking deep into a forest in the middle of the night. One is sweating bullets.
“Hey,” the first one says, “Relax, Vinny. Omertà, remember? No one will ever know we were here.”
Vinny, gulping, replies “Yeah, but what if the trees start talking? I hear this forest is full of…whispering pines.”
Tidbit 3: New Jersey’s Connection to Organized Crime:
In New Jersey, especially in the 20th century, the Mafia had significant influence, and various organized crime families were active in the state. New Jersey has many areas with dense forests, including the Pine Barrens, which could serve as a setting for clandestine activities.
New Joke Idea:
Two Mafia hitmen from North Jersey are walking deep into the Pine Barrens in the middle of the night.
One complains, “I swear, if I gotta look at one more pine tree, I’m gonna lose it! This ain’t the Sopranos no more – this is Blair Witch!.”
The other replies “Will you shut up? Tony Soprano never complained about nothing! Now, remember what we gotta do, and if the locals ask, we’re here looking for the Jersey Devil.”
These additions attempt to layer additional humor by:
- Introducing unexpected elements (talking trees, the Jersey Devil).
- Playing on the inherent tension and fear of the situation.
- Drawing on relevant, but perhaps less obvious, facts about forests and Mafia culture.
- Referring to well-known Mafia stereotypes (The Sopranos).

