I'd like to think he's up there somewhere, watching over me, but obviously he isn't.
thanks Jimmy Carr
Joke Poo:
My goldfish died after I flushed him down the toilet. I’d like to think he’s out there in the sewer system, exploring new depths and adventures, but obviously, he isn’t – he was probably eaten by rats 10 seconds later.
Alright, let’s dissect this morbid morsel!
Joke Breakdown:
- Core Premise: A statement of loss (friend’s death) is juxtaposed with a hopeful sentiment (watching over from above) that is immediately undermined by the harsh reality of the situation (he obviously can’t).
- Humor Element: The humor comes from the ironic contrast between the traditional comforting thought of a deceased person watching over the living and the blunt denial of that possibility due to the specific circumstances of the death. It’s dark, self-deprecating, and tinged with gallows humor.
- Key Elements: Death (skydiving accident), Afterlife (the concept of watching over someone), Reality (the impossibility of the scenario given the death).
Comedic Enrichment Attempt:
Let’s play on the “watching over” concept, using skydiving as the grounding reality.
New Joke/Observation:
“My uncle always said he wanted to be cremated and have his ashes scattered from a plane, so he could finally be ‘looking down’ on us all. The irony is, given his landing skills as a pilot, he’d probably be looking up a lot more.”
Amusing “Did You Know”:
Did you know that the highest skydive ever recorded was from over 128,000 feet? That’s so high, you’d need a pressurized suit to survive. Imagine trying to “watch over” someone from that altitude. You’d be a frozen, hypoxic guardian angel! Good luck squinting through the curvature of the Earth to see if I put the bins out.
Explanation of Enrichment:
- New Joke: This joke similarly inverts the “watching over” idea, but now focuses on incompetence in life (poor piloting skills) rather than the certainty of death. It still retains a dark humor element while being slightly less bleak.
- Did You Know: This plays on the concept of the immense distance implied by the “watching over” trope. By introducing the extreme example of a record-breaking skydive, it highlights the absurdity of trying to observe someone from such a remote location. It makes the “watching over” idea comically impractical.
Both attempts keep the dark humor theme and the core contradiction but introduce new angles and scenarios to amplify the comedic effect. They use the factual tidbit about high-altitude skydiving to further ridicule the notion of oversight from beyond the grave.

