Mexican Police Officer: "So, do you know the criminal Pablo Sanchez?"
Juan (Just Taken Prisoner): "Know him? Yesterday, I am riding my horse,and the horse he stop to make droppings in the road. Pablo Sanchez step out from bushes, holding very big pistola, and tells me to get down. Then he points to the droppings and says, 'you must eat all of that'.
And what can I do? He has the very big gun, so I start to eat. Pablo is laughing. He laughs so hard that he drops the big gun. I quick grab it, and say, 'Now, Pablo, you must eat!'
"And what can Pablo do? I now have the very big gun. So Pablo eat all the rest of that pile.
"So, you ask do I know Pablo Sanchez? Why, just yesterday Pablo and I have lunch together."
Original Joke:
Bandito
Mexican Police Officer: “So, do you know the criminal Pablo Sanchez?”
Juan (Just Taken Prisoner): “Know him? Yesterday, I am riding my horse,and the horse he stop to make droppings in the road. Pablo Sanchez step out from bushes, holding very big pistola, and tells me to get down. Then he points to the droppings and says, ‘you must eat all of that’. And what can I do? He has the very big gun, so I start to eat. Pablo is laughing. He laughs so hard that he drops the big gun. I quick grab it, and say, ‘Now, Pablo, you must eat!’ “
“And what can Pablo do? I now have the very big gun. So Pablo eat all the rest of that pile.”
“So, you ask do I know Pablo Sanchez? Why, just yesterday Pablo and I have lunch together.”
Joke Poo:
CEO’s Dilemma
Board Member: “Tell me, Mr. Henderson, are you acquainted with our competitor, Elon Tusk?”
Henderson (Looking Defeated): “Acquainted? Last week, I was testing our new self-driving car prototype, and the darn thing malfunctioned, stopping right outside Tusk Industries. Elon himself strolls out, holding a shiny new flamethrower, points to the nearest pile of dog poop, and tells me to ‘Devour it for our technological inferiority!’. What could I do? The man had a flamethrower, so I started gagging it down. He was cackling maniacally, enjoying my humiliation so much that he drops the flamethrower. I pounced on it, aimed it right at him, and said, ‘Now, Tusk, you finish the job!'”
“What could Elon do? I had the flamethrower. So, he choked down the rest of the mess, tears streaming down his face.”
“So, you ask if I know Elon Tusk? Well, he and I shared a very memorable appetizer recently.”
Okay, let’s break down this joke and see what comedic fuel we can extract.
Joke Dissection:
- Setup: A Mexican police officer is questioning a newly captured man, Juan, about the bandit Pablo Sanchez.
- Central Premise/Conflict: Juan recounts a story of being victimized by Pablo, forced to eat horse droppings at gunpoint.
- Twist/Punchline: The power dynamic shifts. Juan gains control of the gun and forces Pablo to finish the “meal.” The punchline lies in the euphemistic “lunch together,” suggesting a bizarre, forced camaraderie based on shared trauma (and horse manure).
- Humor Source: The humor stems from:
- Situational Irony: The victim becomes the perpetrator. The tables dramatically turn.
- Gross-Out Humor: The image of eating horse droppings is inherently disgusting and funny (to some).
- Understatement: “Lunch together” is a hilarious understatement of a highly unusual and traumatic event.
- Cultural Nuance/Stereotype (slightly): The joke plays a little on stereotypes of Mexican bandits, but it’s mostly mitigated by the focus on the absurd situation. The accent (written out) adds a light comedic layer.
Key Elements to Exploit for More Humor:
- The Horse Droppings: This is the linchpin of the joke. The grossness is the comedic engine.
- The Power Dynamic/Gun: The shifting control and the “very big gun” are crucial.
- The Understatement (“Lunch Together”): This is a masterstroke of comedic timing and misdirection.
- Pablo’s Laughing: The fact that Pablo is laughing so hard that he drops the gun is what really makes the tale even more outrageous
Comedic Enrichment/New Humor:
Let’s try a “Did You Know?” that enhances the original joke:
“Did you know… coprophages, or dung beetles, have been observed carefully rolling up animal droppings and burying them as a food source or as a place to lay their eggs? So, the next time you’re forced to eat horse manure at gunpoint by a bandit and then force the bandit to eat the rest, remember: you’re both participating in a natural, albeit extremely disgusting, ecosystem function. Perhaps that’s what Juan meant by ‘lunch together’–a shared experience of coprophagic horror!”
Explanation of why this works:
- Relates to the central element: It doubles down on the grossness of the horse droppings.
- Adds an absurd layer of ‘science’: It injects a completely inappropriate scientific factoid into the situation.
- Enhances the understatement: It heightens the absurdity of “lunch together” by suggesting an even more ridiculous interpretation.
- Maintains the tone: The tone is still lighthearted and absurd, like the original.
Alternative Joke:
A tourist in Mexico asks a local: “Is there a difference between a bandit and a politician?”
The local replies: “Well, a bandit makes you eat horse manure at gunpoint… a politician just feeds it to you a spoonful at a time and calls it ‘economic reform’.”
Explanation:
- Mirrors the Power dynamic The joke plays with the element of the ‘big gun’ and the power dynamic that comes with it
- Topical: Connects the premise of the original joke to a more universal observation about power and manipulation.
- Satirical: It offers a satirical commentary on politics and the often-disagreeable things people are forced to accept.

