"I need your help with something!"
He walks in on his wife sitting on the toilet.
"Can you tie my shoe for me, please?"
"You've gotta be kidding me…" the man replies.
"Nope! I shit, you knot."
Joke Poo: The Astronaut’s Dilemma
An astronaut is suited up, ready for a spacewalk outside the International Space Station. He calls out to his crewmate, Mission Control’s voice crackling in his headset, “I need a hand with something!”
His crewmate floats over to the airlock hatch.
“Can you scratch my nose for me, please?” the astronaut asks, his voice muffled by the helmet.
“Are you serious? We’re about to venture into the vacuum of space for a six-hour mission, and you need a nose scratch?” the crewmate retorts, exasperated.
“Yep! I helmet, you feldspar.”
Alright, let’s get to work on this… ahem… knotty problem.
Deconstruction of the Original Joke:
- Setup: Classic “woman in distress” scenario followed by the unexpected setting of the washroom/toilet. This builds anticipation for a significant problem.
- Misdirection: The husband’s entrance and the wife’s request to tie her shoe create comedic tension through absurdity. We expect a real emergency, not a request for basic assistance.
- Punchline: The “I shit, you knot” line is the core of the joke. It’s a pun based on the similar-sounding phrase “I shit, you knot,” creating a vulgar and unexpected twist. The humor lies in the reversal of expectations, the casualness of the request juxtaposed with the gross setting, and the slightly childish pun.
Key Elements:
- Bathroom Humor: Involves bodily functions, specifically defecation.
- Role Reversal: Husband being asked to perform a traditionally feminine task (domestic help).
- Pun/Wordplay: The “shit/knot” word association.
- Husband-Wife Dynamic: Relies on the stereotypical (though often outdated) dynamic of a woman needing her husband’s help, but then subverting it with a cheeky power play.
Comedic Enrichment:
Let’s leverage these elements to create something new! Here are a few options:
Option 1: A “Did You Know?” Extension:
“Did you know that the fear of tying knots is called Koumpounophobia? This is particularly challenging for husbands who get stuck in the ‘I shit, you knot’ scenario. Researchers believe the root cause might stem from childhood experiences involving shoelaces, toilets, and a deep-seated fear of being publicly humiliated by their spouse while in a compromising position. There are, however, therapy groups available. They meet bi-weekly and encourage men to speak openly about their feelings, while simultaneously learning complex macrame techniques.”
- This builds on the original joke by introducing a ridiculous (and partially fabricated) psychological angle. It emphasizes the potential fear the husband might have, amplifying the humour.
Option 2: A New, Related Joke:
“A man is struggling to teach his toddler how to tie their shoes. Frustrated, he calls his wife into the room for help. ‘Honey,’ he groans, ‘I just can’t get him to understand!’ The wife bends down, whispers something into the toddler’s ear, and in an instant, the shoes are tied. Impressed, the husband asks, ‘What did you say to him?’ The wife smiles and replies, ‘I told him if he didn’t learn to tie his shoes, Dad would be stuck wiping his butt forever!'”
- This joke carries over the theme of tying shoes and expands it to a child learning the skill, but the motivation to do so is very toilet humor based
Option 3: A Witty Observation:
“Marriage is a series of increasingly absurd favors. It starts with ‘Will you take out the trash?’ progresses to ‘Will you rub my feet?’, and inevitably peaks with ‘I shit, you knot,’ at which point, you have officially earned your lifetime achievement award in spousal servitude.”
- This focuses on the broader theme of marital roles and expectations, using the punchline from the original joke as a culminating point of absurdity.
Explanation of Choices:
I tried to maintain the core elements of the original joke – the juxtaposition of mundane requests with the potentially unpleasant/unhygienic reality of the bathroom, the power dynamic, and the use of wordplay (though in the “Did You Know?” it’s more subtle). By expanding on these elements with factual or pseudo-factual additions, I aim to create new layers of humor and surprise. The “Did You Know?” approach, in particular, uses mock-seriousness to amplify the ridiculousness of the situation, while the other options provide fresh context for similar themes.

